Can You Do a Metal Roof and Asphalt Shingle Roof Combination

Can You Do a Metal Roof and Asphalt Shingle Roof Combination?

When replacing your roof, you have a world of possibilities in front of you. Standard asphalt shingles are the go-to for most homes, but many homeowners today are exploring combinations of roofing materials for a unique, customized look. One increasingly popular combo? Metal roofing and asphalt shingles.

As a homeowner, I get it – you want your roof to look great and fit your personal style. But melding two different materials brings up a lot of questions.

Can you really mix metal and shingles? Does it look awkward? What are the pros and cons? Let’s dig into the concept and see if an asphalt shingle and metal roof combo could be right for your home.

Key Takeaways

  • It is possible to combine this for a customized look at your home.
  • Metal is usually installed as accents on porches, dormers, etc. while asphalt covers main roof sections.
  • Metal roofing costs more and lasts longer than asphalt, so plan accordingly.
  • Separate warranties apply for each roofing material.
  • Adding metal elements boosts curb appeal with a premium style.
  • Hire an experienced contractor who has done combo installations properly

The Basics: Yes, You Can Combine Metal and Asphalt

The short answer is yes, you absolutely can install a metal and asphalt shingle roof combination on your home. Most often, homeowners will keep standard shingles on the main roof sections and then add metal accents to smaller surfaces like:

  • Front porches
  • Rear porches
  • Side porches
  • Bay windows
  • Dormers
  • Other architectural features

The key benefit of this approach is letting you highlight those areas with the unique look and durability of metal roofing, while still utilizing affordable asphalt shingles on the larger roof planes.

You can even take it a step further by dividing your roof into sections, with metal panels on some facets and asphalt on others. The potential design combinations are virtually unlimited.

However, it’s critical that you work with an experienced contractor who has installed combined roofing systems before. Improperly joining the different materials can lead to leaks and premature deterioration.

4 Must-Know Facts About Metal & Shingle Roofing Combos

Facts About Metal Shingle Roofing Combos

While the possibilities are exciting, there are some important factors to keep in mind when considering a mixed metal and asphalt roof:

  1. Lifespan Differences: Quality asphalt shingles like architectural/dimensional styles can last 25-30 years with proper installation and maintenance. Metal roofing like standing seam panels often has double that longevity at 40-60 years. So, you’ll likely need to re-roof the asphalt sections before replacing the metal.
  2. Cost Considerations: Metal roofing is more expensive than shingles on average. The more metal panels you incorporate, the higher your total installation costs. According to roofing industry data, expect to pay $15+ per square foot for metal versus $4-6 per sq ft for architectural shingles.
  3. Separate Warranties: Manufacturers provide warranties for materials, but these differ for asphalt vs metal. For example, dimensional shingles may come with a 30-year prorated warranty that can be enhanced to 50 years non-prorated if using all brand components. Standing seam metal panels have 30-year warranties for the painted finish, but the metal itself lasts decades longer. Your warranties will cover each roofing type, not an integrated combo system.
  4. Curb Appeal Boost: Let’s be honest – metal roofing looks super sleek and modern compared to traditional shingles. Adding metal accents to asphalt instantly amplifies your home’s curb appeal in a big way. The striking lines, premium materials, and architectural detailing can transform your home’s exterior style.


Does combining metal and shingles look weird?

Not at all if installed properly by an experienced roofer. Metal roofing complements asphalt shingles with a high-end architectural aesthetic. Just be intentional about where you place metal accents for a cohesive design.

If the metal rusts, won’t that damage asphalt sections?

Quality modern metal roofing like steel or aluminium standing seam has specialized coatings like Kynar that prevent rust and deterioration. As long as you maintain it well, rust shouldn’t impact surrounding shingle sections.

Is one roofing type better for certain climates?

Metal performs better than asphalt in very hot, humid conditions and also holds up to severe storms and impacts. Asphalt is a solid all-around choice for most regions. Consider your local climate when deciding how much of each to use.

Can I mix different shingles and metal colors?

Absolutely! Complementing roof colors help tie the two materials together nicely. For example, pair charcoal shingles with a sleek dark gray/black metal accent. Having an experienced installer’s input will ensure a stylish, coordinated look.

How much maintenance is required for each material?

Asphalt shingles mainly need inspections every few years and roof cleaning as needed. Metal roofs require annual inspections and occasional touch-up to screw heads and seams. Overall, metal is much lower maintenance long-term.

The right metal and asphalt shingle combo can give you the best of both worlds – durability and affordability with custom style.

Just be sure to work with pros who can properly design and install your mixed roofing system. With some planning, your new hybrid roof will be the envy of the neighbourhood for decades to come!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *